11/09/2026

A weekly explainer for a fast-moving world

Democrats’ dominant electoral showing last Tuesday left little doubt about who voters blamed for their problems. Voter outrage at Republican mismanagement was so great that Democrats are even on the verge of ousting Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith in Mississippi, a move that would install the state’s first Black senator since 1881. Things could hardly have gone worse for Donald Trump and his now fractured MAGA coalition.

It looks increasingly likely that Democrats will head to Washington with one of the largest congressional majorities in a generation, surpassing the 257 House seats they won in 2008. With as many as 56 seats in the Senate, even spoilsports like Pennsylvania Sen. John Fetterman will be unable to gunk up the party’s plans to hold Trump and his cronies accountable. How Democrats plan to do that, exactly, is a more complicated matter.

This week we’re taking a stab at answering that question by looking at the challenging balancing act facing Democrats in the new Congress. The tightrope between retribution and bipartisanship is narrow and treacherous. Can a resurgent Democratic Party find a way to split the difference without alienating the voters who just elected them?

THE TRUTH ABOUT…

Walking and Chewing Gum

The Hard Work of Governing

Government corruption ranked near the top of voters’ concerns last Tuesday, edged out only by the omnipresent pain of the nationwide affordability crisis. As Donald Sherman, the president and CEO of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, remarked on Thursday, “If this election was about corruption and cost, then this next Congress needs to be focused on accountability and affordability.”

Voters’ sweeping disgust at Republican corruption offers Democrats perhaps their clearest mandate for action — with the added caveat that Americans expect Democrats to be better than the Republicans who ruthlessly weaponized the federal government against Trump’s enemies. That means Democrats need to pick their battles carefully while avoiding the perception that their actions are motivated by vengeance instead of justice. It also means acting on the most glaring examples of Trump’s misconduct first.

Democrats may soon discover some surprising allies in their quest to hold Trump accountable. Congress is expected to vote on GOP Rep. Thomas Massie’s resolution to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth as early as this week. Hegseth has few defenders and plenty of enemies on Capitol Hill, and a growing number of Republicans publicly blame his mismanagement of the Iran War for dooming their midterm hopes. With a little bit of coalition building, Democrats could find enough House Republicans to advance Hegseth’s impeachment to the Senate. Then the embattled Defense Secretary would face a brutal choice: resign in disgrace or risk an uncertain vote in a Senate full of Hegseth critics. 

Claiming Hegseth’s scalp before the new Congress is even in session would prove Democrats’ seriousness about holding the White House accountable. Another opportunity sits just down the road at the Department of Health and Human Services, where Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is facing a wave of high-profile staff resignations. One former adviser, Calley Means, recently accused Kennedy of public corruption and betraying the “Make America Healthy Again” movement. Democrats have already offered Kennedy the same ultimatum they’ve leveled against Hegseth: resign or face impeachment. 

Many House Republicans have lost patience with Kennedy’s antics; some would even gladly lend their help if Democrats were serious about forcing him out. If Democrats play the situation shrewdly, they could drive out two of MAGA’s worst offenders under cover of bipartisan action.

The Trump Problem

Holding Trump personally accountable is another issue entirely. Even in their battered state, few Republicans are willing to publicly levy allegations of corruption and lawlessness against Trump. This is the ground where even Democrats diverge into two camps — the first primarily interested in governing, the second focused almost exclusively on making Trump’s final two years in power a living hell. 

As California Rep. Robert Garcia pointed out in a recent interview, voters made clear last week that they expect Democrats to pursue both courses. But the party’s deep-seated (and entirely justified) hatred of Trump risks derailing the governing side in favor of flashy hearings that capture headlines but fail to actually hold anyone in power accountable. Voters expect more than just symbolic hearing. They overwhelmingly voted for candidates who promised real action to address corporate greed, public corruption, stock trading by legislators and the revolving door of influence peddling between Silicon Valley and the federal government.

The tug-of-war over which course to pursue first is already dividing Democrats. On Friday, House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries, the party’s leading candidate for Speaker of the House, pointedly declined to include impeachment on his list of Democrats’ top priorities. No sooner had Jeffries made his statement than some activist groups on the left accused him of backing off his campaign season promises to seek justice for Trump’s misconduct. 

For now, at least, the mood in the Democratic Party is trending away from a fruitless Trump impeachment and towards consensus accountability policies that could (Jeffries believes) bring along enough Republican votes to override a near-guaranteed presidential veto. A stock trading ban looks almost certain in the new Congress, as does action to bar public officials from participating in prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket.

But Jeffries and current Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer aren’t shying away from investigating what they call Trump’s “tentacles of corruption,” either. One strategy proposed by progressive Democrats would be to use Trump’s misconduct as the rallying point from which Jeffries and his Senate counterparts could propose specific legislation that regulates misconduct beyond Trump’s individual circumstances. That would give Democrats a chance to indulge in Beltway fireworks while still delivering tangible policy wins for voters. 

On Thursday, Schumer took that new approach out for a test-drive with the press.

"Americans want us to clean up corruption in government," Schumer said."No American should have to make tradeoffs at the supermarket while Trump is making inside trades on the stock market."

What Now?

Democrats will have no shortage of targets for investigations and subpoenas when they return to power in January. The tougher job will be deciding which investigations receive priority and when to ask the public for their full attention. Politically exhausted voters will quickly tire of hearings that are all flash and no follow-through, so Democrats will need to ensure that each media spectacle ends with a vote that forces Republicans’ hand on an issue of importance to regular Americans. 

As newly-elected lawmakers begin the grueling process of deciding both their party leadership and their legislative priorities, they will need to balance a voter base eager for action with a party leadership that knows all too well how quickly political capital can disappear if it’s squandered on attacks that don’t yield results. 

After two long years in which they promised the American people accountability for Trump’s reckless presidency, Democrats are now in the position to actually enforce checks and balances on the White House. How the party chooses to move forward will be every bit as important as where they strike first.

ICYMI

How To Repair America

For millions of Americans, life feels harder than it should. The systems shaping daily life, from housing and healthcare to rights and representation, are under visible strain, and the gap between what is promised and what is delivered continues to widen.

Repairing America is a DAME series that moves beyond documenting crises to examining how these systems were built, where they break down, and what it would take to fix them. Across reported pieces grounded in policy expertise and lived experience, this series focuses on real, attainable solutions designed to make life better for all Americans.